Friday, June 19, 2015

The Post-McDonalds era of restaurants…

When I was younger and my parents would drive on trips to Cincinnati and to Valparaiso, McDonalds would always figure in where we stopped.  Whether it was the one just north of Knoxville, TN or the one in Elizabethtown, KY, or the dozen or so Mickey Ds we stopped at during our long 2 week trip in 1981 across the Eastern US and Ontario, CN, we always used the Golden Arches as a rest and recharging stop.  Partly because my sisters worked briefly at the Snellville location, but also because we knew we could rely on the quality of the food there, even though it was cheap.  You always knew you could find something to eat there.

As I went off to college and moved on to adulthood, my stops to the familiar McD logo got rarer.  Sure I worked at McDs main burger rival, Burger King, during HS and College days, but I also discovered that there was more to stops than just grabbing Chicken McNuggets, Fries, and a Sprite while driving the Interstate routes.  When I started dating my wife, I always wanted to try new places to see what I liked and what I didn’t.  McDs never figured into our date nights until after my kids were born.  After my kids were born, McDs visits started up again, but was largely in rotation with BK, Wendy’s, Arby’s, Chick-Fil-A, and other “cheap restaurants”.

This year, however, McDs visits have gotten fewer and fewer… even though there are tons of Golden Arches around.  And I am not the only one that has stopped going to the familiar logo.  McDonalds is going through a major slump in the US.  The chain that we all grew up with as kids has hit a wall.  People still go there, but not in the numbers or frequency they once did.  There are a number of reasons, but the upshot is this:  For the first time since at least stats were tracked on McDonalds growth starting in 1970, the Golden Arches will close more stores than it will open in 2015…  A shocking reality for one of the biggest property owners in the US.

So let’s look at some of the reasons for the decline of the Golden Arches:

(1) MCDONALDS ONCE TRIED TO BE A JACK OF ALL TRADES… AND WASN’T GREAT AT ANYTHING.  In their attempts to get more people into McDonalds, they have tried to have all sorts of options to compete with burger rivals, chicken rivals, fresh food rivals… and they forgot the basics, which is what they were good at.  They tried to be hip to adults at the expense of losing families who just wanted to get a Happy Meal for their kids or play on a playground.  And they forgot about quality of food, fast service, clean stores, and cheap prices.  A Big Mac meal now costs about $6 in many places, and has less quality than 20-30 years ago. 

(2) COMPETITION IS FIRECE NOW.  McDonalds is facing a myriad of new and old rivals chipping away at their dominance. Taco Bell and Subway is challenging with Breakfast offerings.  Dunkin Donuts and Starbucks are also trying to get Breakfast Numbers away from McDonalds.  Chick-Fil-A has superior service in most locations, and has a stranglehold on Chicken Sandwich offerings.  Chipotle is making inroads with a new generation of customers that believe in fresh food.  Five Guys and other fancier burger places are even challenging the Golden Arches’ Burger Supremacy.  Burger King and Wendy’s are inputting Coca-Cola Freestyle Machines in an effort to get customers in their store.  Popeye’s is winning over people with their Fried Chicken.  And that doesn’t even account for Sit-Down Places that offer new food that McDonalds can’t even compete with.  For me, McDonalds is sort of at the bottom of the list of places I want to go to.  I’d rather go to places like Nando’s or Mission BBQ or the soon to be arriving in Maryland Steak and Shake before I would go to McDonalds.  Sorry.

(3) MCDONALDS ATTEMPTS TO REINVENT THEMSELVES HAVE BEEN DISASTEROUS.  In recent months, McDonalds has gotten rid of half their menu items.  Gone were mid-priced Chicken Sandwiches, variations of their Quarter Pounder with Cheese Burgers, and other sandwiches that underperformed.  McDonalds tried to offer a new way of ordering Value Meals that left many people confused (although I loved the idea of picking and choosing what things I wanted to have with my value meal).  That lasted three months before they changed back to what they used to do for value meals.  They got rid of the Dollar Menu, then brought it back.  They have been schizophrenic and it has angered customers more.

(4) THERE ARE JUST TOO MANY MCDONALDS AROUND IN SOME AREAS… NOT ENOUGH IN OTHERS.  Within 15 minutes of my house, there are about 10-12 McDonalds… far more than any other restaurant chain in the area.  They could probably dump half of those restaurants and still turn a corporate profit.  Do you really need Golden Arches of either side of Ritchie Hwy in Severna Park? Do you need 3 McDs within 5 miles along Mountain Road?  Meanwhile, McDonalds are fewer in other parts of the country. 

(5) MCDONALDS IS LIKE SEARS AND RADIO SHACK… IN A BAD WAY.  McDonalds in the 1980s was like Radio Shack and Sears… Dominant.  They were the top dogs and they acted like arrogant top dogs.  They oversaturated (especially Radio Shack).  Look at them now.  The Radio Shacks that are left are turning into Sprint outlets.  Sears may be dead in another decade.  McDonalds?  They probably won’t die out… yet. But more and more, McDonalds’ reputation is sinking lower and lower in the eyes of many people.  McDonalds needs to change course and fast.  Otherwise, maybe even the Golden Arches is not be immune to Chapter 11.

The next decade will see a reshuffling of restaurants as they try to vie for the title of most recognized US restaurant.  McDonalds could figure out what they need to do to remain at/return to the top, or they could slowly descend into irrelevance while other restaurants battle for the crown.  At this point, who knows.  One thing is certain, however:  The era of McDonalds dominance is over… and unlikely to go back to the way it once was.

Friday, May 1, 2015

This person is the biggest loser in the Baltimore Riots…

Regardless of your opinion of what happened regarding the death of Freddie Grey, regardless of your thoughts about the week of peaceful protests that sadly turned violent last Saturday night and again two days later, regardless of what Baltimore Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake said or didn’t say that may or may not have given the green lights to the cowards who looted the city, regardless of the feelings people have about the use of the word “thugs”, regardless of which politician looks strongest in the aftermath of the riots and the State of Emergency that followed… It is clear that one person has lost a lot of credibility in the aftermath.  And it may cost this person dearly in the coming months.  His actions over the last 15 years set the stage for the disaster which followed.  At this point, he may be less popular in the city of Baltimore than the current Republican Governor of Maryland.  He is clearly the biggest loser of the Baltimore riots.

That person is Former Mayor of Baltimore, Former Governor of Maryland, and possible 2016 Democratic Presidential Candidate, Martin O’ Malley.  Surprised?  You shouldn’t be, if you have been following Baltimore politics since the 1990s.  O’ Malley used the city as a springboard for higher public office, but his decision-making set the stage for what followed.

Flashback to 1999, the last time Baltimore had any semblance of a competitive Mayoral Election.  Many of the state of Maryland’s Democratic party elder were lamenting the fact that the city of Baltimore was descending into chaos that was shown in fictional TV shows like “Homicide: Life on the Streets” and later “The Wire”.  Outgoing mayor Kurt Schmoke had done nothing to stem the tide of 300+ murders a year annually throughout the 1990s.  The party leaders wanted a mayor who could help remake Baltimore’s image and help bring in desperately needed money to help the struggling city.  Those leaders were begging Kweisi Mfume, then the head of the NAACP, to run for the top city job.  Mfume toyed with the idea, before ultimately declining.  That refusal to take the Mayor’s position may have cost Mfume when he ran for US Senate in 2006.  But back to the 1999 Mayor’s contest…

Without Mfume in the race, three main candidates from the City Council formed a spirited Democratic primary.  The anointed favorite was City Council President Lawrence Bell.  Councilman Carl Stokes (who recently remarked that instead of calling the rioters thugs, they should be called the N-Word) was considered the main rival.  O’ Malley, also on the city council, was the third person in the race.  Other names were in the race, but they were largely afterthoughts.

Bell and O’Malley focused on a “Zero-Tolerance” policy for criminals in their campaigns.  Stokes did not.  It clearly caused controversy in a town that was overwhelming African-American, where Zero Tolerance policing was considered a code word for racial profiling in many eyes.  During the campaign, Stokes managed to gain traction on Bell by attacking Bell’s views on crime.  O’Malley and Bell also had opposed the state taking over Baltimore City School in the mid-1990s due to the failing standards the city schools had been dealing with for many years.

In the end, all three candidates split the African-American vote.  But O’Malley won nearly all of the non-African-American vote in what turned into a surprisingly easy primary win as he got 52% of the overall vote.  The Democratic primary effectively was the election, as O’Malley won the general elections with 90% of the vote.

O’Malley highlighted using New York City’s Zero-Tolerance gun control policy, so it made sense that he picked a former high-ranking NYPD officer by the name of Ed Norris to be Baltimore’s top cop.  With O’Malley in charge, the city appeared to have turned a corner in terms of being a safer place to work, live, and play.  Coupled with the rise of the Ravens as an NFL powerhouse, things on the surface looked better.

But O’Malley’s views were not popular everywhere in the city, and nowhere so distinctly than the city’s west side.  The Western District had never really fully recovered from the 1968 riots in the aftermath of the Dr. King Assassination. Crime dominated the area.  And while the Zero-Tolerance policy was working, many in those areas felt the police were being given too much latitude in dealing with suspects.  They were suspicious of O’Malley and Norris.

Soon though, O’Malley was being hailed as the next generation of  Democratic Party leaders and so most of the city looked past O’Malley’s transgressions.  After Republican Bob Ehrlich upset Kathleen Kennedy-Townsend in the 2002 Governor’s election, O’Malley was looked upon by the Democratic leadership as the Democrats top voice in dissent.  And it got personal really quick as Gov. Ehrlich first tried to pluck Ed Norris away from O’Malley by nominating Norris as Maryland’s Top Cop.  Parts of Norris’ past came up, and O’Malley threw his one-time police commissioner under the bus.  Norris would ultimately be forced to withdraw consideration, and today hosts a morning talk-show in Baltimore.  Ehrlich then tried to once-again use the state to take over the Baltimore City Schools, but O’Malley wouldn’t allow it.  When the two finally clashed in the 2006 Gubernatorial Campaign, the bad blood between the two was at an all-time high.  Despite Ehrlich being very popular with the voters of MD, O’Malley won the election, then beat back Ehrlich again in 2010.

With O’Malley gone from the city of Baltimore, City Council President Sheila Dixon took over as Mayor and tried to soften O’Malley’s position on crime.  But after a few years, she was found guilty of taking gift cards intended for Baltimore’s poor youth and using it for her own benefit.  Her resignation in 2010 paved the way for then-City Council President Stephanie Rawlings-Blake to become mayor, which she currently is.

But people on Baltimore never forgot about O’Malley’s tenure as Mayor.  Though his impact was seen as positive by many—first as mayor, then as two-term Governor—some could not forget his views on criminals when he was Mayor of the city.  It may have manifested itself in last year’s Gubernatorial Election, where O’Malley’s hand picked successor, Anthony Brown (an African-American) was stunned by Republican Larry Hogan.  The post-election analysis proved telling.  In a city where Democrats, and especially African-American Democrats do very well in elections, Brown won easily, but it was by a far less percentage than what was needed to overcome Hogan’s superior advantage in the suburbs.  Many African-Americans probably chose not to vote in protest over O’Malley’s legacy.  A few even voted for Hogan, because Hogan actually campaigned in Baltimore City and cared enough to do so.

In the aftermath of the riots, Hogan has been on the ground in Baltimore, talking with the people of the city and with its leaders.  Though some may have criticized him giving the impression of throwing Mayor Rawlings-Blake under the bus for her response to the crisis on Monday, Hogan has shown a willingness to help out and appears to have shown a strong, yet caring hand in the situation.

As for O’Malley, he really hasn’t been around Maryland much since the elections.  He’s been too busy trying to be a potential rival to Hillary’s steamroller of a campaign for President next year.  But O’Malley’s national silence on the Baltimore situation has been deafening. 

O’Malley returned to Baltimore on Tuesday.  It was a disaster.  First, O’Malley had to ask an aide if it was safe to walk the streets of West Baltimore and talk with people.  Then, after being assured it was, he did—only to be heckled by residents who still remember his tenure as Mayor and how they believe it set the stage for the death of Freddie Grey.  Despite positive comments by some church leaders, the damage was done—perhaps fatal to his dreams of becoming President.

O’Malley is back on the pre-campaign trail.  Some have suggested a major speech is planned.  But O’Malley’s sins will haunt him if he runs for President.  Hillary is seen in a better light, especially after recent comments.  In the end, Martin O’Malley will likely be sitting the 2016 Presidential General Election on the sidelines, instead of being the nominee.  Baltimore’s sins have come home to roost on O’Malley.

Thursday, March 12, 2015

LTE Today: The long-awaited rise of the Dragon…

Sometime shortly after the New Year of 2015, an important milestone for LTE was crossed.  In some corner of the planet, the 500,000,000th LTE Subscriber was activated.  It is a remarkable achievement for a wireless technology that just over 10 years ago was first being proposed as a wireless technology.

I’ve blogged about how LTE was going to blow away WiMAX as early as 2010.  Heck, before LTE’s first network was activated in 2009, T-Mobile’s Neville Ray predicted that LTE would have 99% of the 4G market by the end of 2014.  He wasn’t too far off… LTE had at least 95% of the 4G market.  Now, LTE is sounding the death knell for CDMA technology, and it could render all 3G wireless technologies obsolete within 5-10 years.

LTE has continued to outpace even the most optimistic of projections regarding how the technology would grow over time.  At least 375 LTE networks are currently active across 130 countries.  Although LTE’s footprint is relatively small compared with older wireless technologies, it has been positioned and initially launched in large metropolitan areas, where LTE’s simplified architecture is prized over more complicated 3G networks.  In some countries, like the US, expansion has taken place to the point where now, over 99% of the citizens have access to a functioning LTE network.

And the one prediction I made in 2010 that was wrong as of 2012 has staged a remarkable reversal.  Mainland China has finally launched LTE across 3 networks using TD-LTE and it has been a huge launch.

Right now, the US is the largest LTE country in terms of subscribers with just under 150 million subscribers—mostly AT&T and Verizon Wireless customers (shut up John Legere, I’ve seen the numbers, you and Sprint combined are lucky to maybe have 20% of the total LTE share in the US).  But China is rapidly moving up the ladder.  Currently in 2nd place with about 100 million subscribers across its three networks, China is expected to pass the US in terms of number of LTE subscribers by around mid-year.  China’s largest cellular network, China Mobile, just blew past AT&T and Verizon to become the world largest LTE subscriber base, even though its network footprint is so small.  Heck, China Mobile is so big, Apple provided China Mobile with its own unique iPhone models. 

What the rise of China as a Wireless Force has done is that, for the first time ever, China is a major player in the Wireless World.  For many years, Europe and the US were the innovators in Wireless Technology, with Japan having an impact as well.  China was always playing catch-up.  They yearned for the day when they would have significant input on wireless technologies.  With LTE (in particular, TD-LTE), China has finally achieved being a voice in wireless tech.  And with 5G now being proposed and tested against, China can write a technology of its own that the world can accept as a global standard.

In the end, China will return to a glory they have seen over most of the last 2000 years.  What happens after they replace the US as Top Dog in LTE? Who cares?  For now, LTE is the great wireless technology… At least until 5G comes around.

Tuesday, February 10, 2015

The End of the Post-Johnny Carson Late Night Era…

Sometime later this year, the Post Johnny Carson Late Night Era in TV will, for all practical purposes, end with the retirement of David Letterman and the departure of Jon Stewart. When Johnny retired in May 1992, many of us wondered how we would soldier on without our favorite late night host. For the last 23 years, a variety of late night hosts have tried to fill Johnny’s shoes. While no one could individually, a group of hosts did an admirable job carrying on Johnny’s tradition.

Jay Leno. David Letterman. Jon Stewart. Craig Ferguson. And a host of others showed that life moved on after Johnny. Each late night talk show host brought their own variation of Johnny’s formula with a mix of their own style to the post-11pm crowd with varying degrees of success. Leno sat in Johnny’s chair at NBC and continued NBC’s domination of late night. Letterman had Johnny’s genius and support at CBS, while more than holding his own ratings-wise. Letterman also introduced his own prodigies in people like Craig Kilborn and Craig Ferguson. Kilborn would also entertain a brief run as host of The Daily Show on Comedy Central before a relatively unknown comedian named Jon Stewart would take the reins and send The Daily Show into the stratosphere for 15 years.

But now, they are leaving late night for various reasons and pursuing future endeavors. Leno, who retired last year, is pursuing his long-time passion for cars and occasionally pops up here and there on the comedy scene. Kilborn could not handle the national spotlight for long, and was last seen back in LA doing local TV. Ferguson lost out as heir apparent to Letterman—and got paid nicely for his trouble. His future is unknown, but it’s clear he may be heard from again. When Letterman retires, he will likely follow his mentor’s cues and ride off into the sunset, rarely returning to the spotlight post-Late Show. As for Stewart, he will either move over to the director’s chair, or become a major network news anchor.

The next generation replacing these late night hosts are already taking over.  Jimmy Fallon has replaced Leno in The Tonight Show Chair, and he has backup with Seth Meyers on Late Night. Jimmy Kimmel is given ABC a foothold in late night. Stephen Colbert, whose big break was thanks to Jon Stewart is Letterman’s heir apparent at CBS. And Comedy Central will find it’s next John Stewart, though it may take some time.

There are holdovers, to be sure.  Conan O’Brien, who was once Leno’s heir at NBC is still hanging on at TBS, although I suspect he has a retirement plan in place by the end of this decade. And Bill Maher, who started on ABC before getting a weekly show on HBO is still around, though his time is growing short as well. But for all practical purposes, the first generation after Johnny is calling it a day.

How will history judge these “children of Johnny” in late night? And can the next generation prove they, too, can thrive in a late night setting, like their predecessors?  Maybe we’ll know the full answer in about 15-20 years. For now, let’s treasure the moments we have with what’s left of the post-Johnny generation before they disappear.

Friday, January 2, 2015

Why Twitter is a “loaded gun”…

Steve Czaban of ESPN Radio Washington & Yahoo! Sports Radio once famously remarked that Twitter was a loaded gun.  After a controversial tweet in late 2012, Czaban had to deal with a firestorm of criticism.  He ultimately went into a self-imposed Twitter exile that lasted most of 2013.  The point: one wrong Tweet, and you could be in the trained crosshairs of certain groups.  Several celebs have been taken down because of Tweets.  Even the most innocuous of Tweets can find you in a world of trouble (just ask Bill Cosby and others).

Two tweets in the past week hammered that point personally home to me.  One was perhaps my most controversial Tweet to date.  The other came from CBS Radio & TV Talk Show Host Jim Rome, whose Twitter’s account I follow. 

First, my tweet.  Last Saturday Morning, the funeral for NYPD Officer Ramos took place.  Ofc. Ramos was 1 of 2 NYPD Officers assassinated apparently in retaliation for the deaths of 2 unarmed suspects at the hands of police in NYC and Ferguson, MO.  And yes, my controversial tweet concerned the funeral. 

Now I know what you are thinking… I went after NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio and his apparent lack of concern for NYPD Officers, right? Wrong. OK, maybe I went after the protestor who chanted for dead cops? Nope. OK, maybe I tweeted a scathing rebuke of the NYPD Officers who turned their backs on the Mayor’s eulogy, right? Guess again.

Here was my “controversial tweet”, which I later deleted:

"Interesting note about today's funeral for NYPD Ofc. Ramos... No Westboro Baptist Church members in sight to protest".

That’s it?!? On a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 was minimal controversy and 10 was asking for trouble, I felt that tweet was a 2 at worst. No hastag, No @ address deliberately trying to egg on the church. Nothing. I felt that I had tweeted much worse snark about Ravens games this season.  No big deal, right? That was. until the alleged real Westboro Baptist Church, who clearly had their rabbit ears up, came back at me.  I captured some images of the responses.  First from the alleged Church themselves, they tweeted a picture trying to indicate they were there (which obviously, they weren’t).  If they were in NYC, they were clearly nowhere near the funeral; otherwise, they would have never made it out the Queens borough alive. Then they tried to tell me I was going to hell. Then the coup de grace. They lumped me in with VP Joe Biden, Al Sharpton, and the NYPD, praying for me to stop marrying gays. I kid you not!

I found the attention these “Christians” (and I use that term VERY loosely) directed at me to be funny.  I even joked about it on FB.  The fact the WBC Cult would be scared of lil’ ol’ me shows how far they have fallen.  Once upon a time, we used to get upset when they would protest funerals, like Matthew Shepard’s, soldiers who died in combat, celebrities, and even little victims of the Newtown, MA shooting. Now, they have been reduced to coming after nobodies. They excommunicated their founder before he died because he apparently softened his anti-gay stance in a moment of compassion. They are losing family members, who are coming to the reality that their hell, fire, and brimstone preaching about gays all the time is counterproductive.

Still, I made a mistake.  I gave them something they are in desperate need.  Attention. And a reason to hate.  They probably preached a sermon about me last Sunday, thinking I am some major agent of the devil. Not my intention, but I gave them something to chew on.  So I have decided to not do that again. If they need me and others to even comment about them in order to keep surviving on hate, it is time to stop giving them attention.  If we can ignore them, they will eventually disappear—whether peacefully (as in they will stop believing their hatred) or… well, think Jonestown, Guyana and Jim Jones.

Jim Rome, stirred up a controversy of a different kind during halftime of yesterday’s Rose Bowl in an apparent reference to Florida State’s Marching Band.  His tweet (also now deleted) went like this:

“Is there anyone not in a marching band who thinks those dorks running around with those instruments are cool?”

This was a reset of a take he unloaded over 5 years ago concerning “Marching Band Guy”.  Over the years, Rome has taken on various “Guys” who think they are athletes, but are really not in his mind… Guys like “Softball Guy”, “Soccer Guy”, “Bowling Guy”, “Fitness Guy”, “Pickup Basketball Guy”, “Fantasy Football Guy”, etc.  “Marching Band Guy” was one of his last Guys he ripped on.  And I know this was over 5 years ago, because that take is older than Joshua.

Anyways, as someone who has listened to “Van Smack” over the years, who used to be “Marching Band Guy”, and who still considers himself a “Bowling Guy”, I have had no issues Rome’s takes on “Marching Band Guy” or “Bowling Guy”. He played to his radio audience. No big deal. And I saw his tweet about the Marching Band last night and thought, “He’s just looking to ruffle some listeners’ feathers up a little.” I had heard worse when I was a South Gwinnett Band of Stars Member and verbal crap was hurled in my direction coming from the Drumline and Low Brass sections during Band Camps at the GA 4-H Camp.

Well, apparently, it stirred up a hornet’s nest.

Maybe it was the fact that Marching Bands have been dealing with negative press in recent years.  Like Florida A&M’s Marching Band, whose Famed group was suspended for a year after the death of a Drum Major exposed a major hazing culture that existed into this decade.  Like Ohio State’s Band, whose decades of hypersexualized culture was exposed last year, leading to the firing of their Band Director. Like the High School Director in Alabama who turned after school tutoring of female students into his own “Fifty Shades of Grey” fantasies that the young ladies were all too eager to satisfy. Like the fact that when most people think Marching Band Movies, they think of “American Pie” and what you can do with a flute at Band Camp instead of “Drumline”.

So the Band folks snapped last night and went after the “Pimp in the Box” in such a huge way that Rome was forced to make a rare apology.  And by forced, I mean that CBS probably told him they were feeling the heat and that he was potentially costing them money.  Rome could get away with it years ago when he had his own syndicated radio network and didn’t have to answer to a major company. He no longer has that ability now that he’s ultimately answering to Jim McKay’s son.

Again, I had no problem with Rome’s controversial post, because I used to be a Scrawny Marching Band Dork who wasn’t cool. But some Marching Band people were offended.  They thought Rome was being a bully, even though some of them acted like Marching Band Bullies in High School Band.  That’s what I find ironic. And look, just because you wake up early for 5:00 am Band Practice doesn’t mean you are more athletic than an athlete. I know this firsthand. After my three years of Marching Band, I tried out for the Basketball team at South Gwinnett my Senior Year-and didn’t make the cut. The Basketball conditioning kicked my butt in more ways than anything Mitch Lavender had ever put me through during a Band Camp (a Back-to-Front Sprint--known by a more insensitive name--was considered a Cool-Down day? Seriously, Coach Mudd?)

Anyways, the Band folks can call off the hounds now… Further agitation would be just piling on.  Marching Band Guy (and probably the rest of the “Guys”) has now joined “The Rat Family” in something Rome will never bring up on air or Twitter ever again.

As I said in the beginning, Twitter (even more so than Facebook) is a loaded gun.  Choose to use it wisely. From now on, I’ll try to focus on Sports and Tech—maybe Tweet an Election Day take whenever that happens. I’d like to think those things are innocuous… But I (and Jim Rome) must realize some people will always have their rabbit ears up…

So… “What’s Popping Twitter??” Winking smile

Monday, November 17, 2014

The Price of Net Neutrality (a.k.a. “Your WiFi or Your Landline” or “A Tale of Two Internets”)

Net Neutrality recently became a hot news topic when President Obama voiced support for the cause.  The issue which has largely simmered in the back rooms of technical discussions has now burst onto the scene with everyone seemingly now having an opinion—and most of those opinions unaware about the ramifications about what net neutrality means.

Now don’t get me wrong.  Opinions are nice—when you aren’t regurgitating 5-10 year old arguments for and against net neutrality.  The issue has become extremely complicated in recent years as the internet has gone from just dealing with PCs to dealing with the IoT (or Internet of Things—basically means everything from computers to cell phones to refrigerators to TVs to Smart meters to well any personal device that can connect to the Internet).  And some hard choices are going to have to be made in the near future—choices that some who support net neutrality will not like.

The next 10 years are going to be the most critical in the transformation of communication systems in our country.  The problem is that we did not address the potential pitfalls of the internet within the past 20 years and the failure to do so has now put the communications networks of this country on the brink of rolling blackouts or freezes.  Asking Tier I Cellular Companies to increase capacity but enforce net neutrality is going to have major consequences as more and more devices (perhaps as many as 50 billion devices worldwide within 10 years) access the Internet.  And with newer generations technologies, like LTE and LTE-Advanced unable to keep up with the exponentially growing demand, it’s going to get ugly soon, unless radical changes are made.  Those changes will be felt far beyond the Wireless world.

Tom Wheeler, who was appointed FCC Chairman by President Obama last year was given an thankless & impossible task: begin addressing bringing communications in this country up to the 21st century.  The previous FCC Chairman, Julius Genachowski, had laid down some pretty audacious goals in his years that Wheeler now has to develop a plan for.  And Wheeler’s boss just threw a live hand grenade into Wheeler’s lap with his net neutrality wishes. 

At the same time, younger people are moving away from the more traditional means of home communications.  Their mobile devices allow them to be free to move at will and not be constrained by certain area codes or tethered to wired Internet access.  More and more, younger people are cutting the cords and lines all together, putting strains on wireless networks, yet these younger people still demand faster and better internet experiences at the same price.  So better, faster, and still cheap.

To increase a user experience, more capacity has to be added to meet the increasing demand.  More capacity can be added in 3 ways: Spectral efficiency, more cell phone towers, and more available Wireless spectrum.  Without adequate capacity, the Mobile Internet will grind to a halt.

My thoughts on Net Neutrality are as follows: if Net Neutrality is going to be implemented, then Wireless Providers are going to have to be freed up to optimize the experience for all.  That means the following:

(1) MORE WIRELESS SPECTRUM MUST BE ALLOCATED TO WIRELESS PROVIDERS:  Obviously this meets the more Spectrum aspect that providers need to provide better service.  The Federal Government must act on the recommendations the FCC and the Obama Administration made back in 2009 of adding 500 MHz of spectrum to be used in Wireless by 2020.  Only now are auctions for newer spectrum bands starting to take shape—the first since the famed 700 MHz auctions in 2008.  What is being provided now (about 110 MHz) is woefully inadequate to meet the increasing demands.

(2) TIME TO KISS 2G & 3G TECHNOLOGIES GOODBYE… AND HELLO VOLTE:  I bet you didn’t know that even the iPhone 6 makes calls on a nearly 20-year old cellular network in the US.  Oh, it’s true.  You think a faster iPhone gives you better phone call quality?  Wrong.  For the most part, it’s still making calls on the original digital cellular technologies, such as GSM and CDMA.  But that is changing as we speak.  T-Mobile, Verizon, and AT&T are all rolling out VoLTE technology.  Think of it as HD Voice for your mobile device.  The calls are clearer, the latencies are shorter, and it’s a better overall experience.  But instead of having it’s own dedicated voice channels, VoLTE uses the LTE data network.  Your voice is spliced up into 1s and 0s and transmitted like data packets just like internet traffic.  Your voice in fact becomes internet traffic.  Telcos were having a devil of a time implementing this.  You see, wireless providers get most of their money from SMS messages (Texting) and Voice Calls.  Data traffic, and Video gives Wireless Providers very little in terms of profit.  So, there was no push to go to VoLTE.  But with Bandwidth becoming more precious, they no longer have any choice but to implement VoLTE.  In turn, the Wireless Providers are gradually turning off the older cellular network and recapitalizing that spectrum for 4G purposes in sort of a carrier-aggregation aspect.  Verizon is setting a 2021 deadline for ending 2G & 3G services.  AT&T intends to end 2G services in 2 years.  This will account for the spectral efficiency component to increase network capacity. 

(3) THE GAPS MUST BE FILLED IN… AND REDUNDANT BACKUP POWER SUPPLIES MUST BE ACCOUNTED FOR:  9/11, the Earthquake in Virginia in 2011, and Superstorm Sandy exposed the limitations of Wireless Networks.  If everyone tries to get on the network in the same area at the same time, the network will jam itself.  The Wireless Networks are ill-equipped at this time to handle such a volume.  Sandy exposed something worse.  In times of natural disasters, improper backup power supplies located in the wrong places could knock out networks in local areas for weeks. 

If you are going to have the best wireless networks around, you need smaller “cell towers” in heavily populated areas to offload some of the traffic with even smaller cells in residential areas.  This meets the more towers requirement without having to put giant cell towers every 500 feet in this country.  Mixing Small Cell Tower with Larger Cell Towers gives us Heterogeneous Networks (or HetNets for short). HetNet technology is not just a fantasy; it’s here & now.  All the major Wireless Carriers are deploying them as we speak.  In a few short years, small cells will account for 86% of all internet connections.  And Backup Power Supplies (think solar, for example) must be available in case restoring the network in certain locales takes time.  In short, if you are going to put a small Cell Tower on top of a beachfront hotel, don’t put the backup Power Supply in the basement where a Hurricane could flood it and short out the power.

So we have accounted for the main needs Wireless Networks have to meet the increasing demand.  But two other needs must be met in order for Wireless Networks to achieve their full potential…

(4) TERMINATE THE COPPER WIRELINE TELEPHONE NETWORK MANDATES:  AT&T, Verizon, and CenturyLink comprise most of the original Ma Bell, which had to maintain copper lines built after WWII allowing people to communicate via telephone.  In this day and age, few young people know how to maintain those 50+ year old lines.  While fiber is being used in modern networks around big cities, fiber has a nasty little aspect to it… Maintaining connections becomes more the responsibility of the end user, rather than the provider as was the case with Copper.  You see that with AT&T’s U-Verse and Verizon’s FiOS systems.  If the power goes out, you have roughly an 8-hour battery life before your home phone dies.  The Fiber network still operates, but it relies on the power of the backup battery in your home. In the old copper days, network redundancies and the low power consumption allowed phone calls to be made even when power was out for days at a time.  In fact, the Government mandated the Old Ma Bell had to maintain those copper lines as a “Carrier of Last Resort” in times of natural disasters.

But with kids moving away from the guaranteed reliable wired networks into wireless networks, why should AT&T, and Verizon be forced to maintain an aging network?  It can’t be expected to.  My guess is that if the FCC forces Tier I Cell providers like AT&T and Verizon to met net neutrality obligations, a trade-off will be made which will eliminate the carrier of last resort mandates nationwide.  In short, the old Copper Wired Telephone Network will die… and with it, most of the unionized workforce that the children of Ma Bell Employ.  In its stead, a more IP-based protocol system (what 4G LTE networks have now) will be put in place allowing for fiber and/or wireless networks to provide some semblance of continued continuity for those who still rely on making a phone call while delivering other services, such as TV and Internet to users as well.  But it will not be as reliable.  Call it a hunch, but the end of the Old Wired Telephone Network will happen before the end of this decade.  There may be still Copper Lines in Rural areas as AT&T and Verizon sells those lines off to Mom & Pop Companies.  But in the cities & suburbs, fiber and Wireless will replace Copper.

Even with ending Copper Line Connectivity, and meeting all the wireless network requirements to make the internet better, the fact is 90% of the Internet is still ruled by porn.  The thought of 50 billion mobile devices looking mostly for oiled-up naked Kim Kardashian butt pics is disturbing, but there is another solution… if people want to pay for it…

(5) A SEPARATE, SECURE, AND PAY-INTERNET MUST BE ESTABLISHED TO ALLOW HIGHER-SPEED AND GUARANTEED ACCESS:  In short, a Second Internet must be established.  This Internet will be more reliable, allow for greater security, and will allow for faster access.  No porn on this second Internet.  But in order to access this guaranteed faster Internet, you will have to pay and if you try to hack the network, you will be kicked off of the new internet.  Think of it as a tollway interstate system where the speed limit is unlimited, but breaking the rules means you can never access it again.

There are still disruptive ways to connect to the Internet. WiFi is being used now, and LTE-Direct could be an interesting way to access the Internet. But if people still want to be connected to the outside world via a relatively cheap internet, the Government must provide the tools to wireless companies to make the experience work… and eliminate antiquated wired rules.  You want net neutrality, fine.  But you’ll “pay”… one way or another.

Sunday, November 9, 2014

An Inconvenient Counterexample about Elections & Money

So the post-modem about the 2014 election is largely political analysts trying to explain how they were so wrong about the polling in the final days leading up to the election.  It’s impossible to think those tea-party  extremist Republicans could have won so decisively over those caring Democrats, they surmise.  It has also focused on the Koch brothers and how these analysts claim they bought all the elections for the Republicans (ignoring the fact that Democrats have their own fat cat donors in the form of George Soros and others).  But that’s not the point…

When smart people make stupid generalizations about events that happen, I always go looking for counterexamples to combat their lazy assumptions.  This time, I didn’t have go looking far.  So OK smart-asses…

Explain Maryland’s 2014 Gubernatorial Election.

Democrats hold a registration advantage of 2 to 1 over Republicans in this state.  They have held nearly all of the top offices in the state over the last 45 years.  The last three United States Senators have come from the same reliably Democrat 3rd US House District.  Democrats outnumber Republicans in the state by much more than a 2 to 1 margin (it has often been joked that the Republicans in Annapolis could hold their caucus meetings in a broom closet).  Maryland is often considered the most progressive state in the Union.

The Democrat strongholds in Maryland are focused on two areas:  Baltimore City, and the DC suburbs of Montgomery & Prince George’s Countries.  Baltimore City & Prince George’s County have a heavy African-American presence, while Montgomery County is home to many ultra-rich progressives.  Those three areas have more than counteracted any Republican insurgencies (see 1994 as a Prime example).

For the last 8 years, the Maryland Governor has been Martin O’ Malley.  He has seemingly had his way in Annapolis.  Two years ago, he successfully pushed 7 ballot initiatives through the legislature, then through referendum (those initiatives included legalizing same-sex marriage, in-state tuition for illegal immigrants, and legalizing table games at Maryland Casinos—did I mention O’Malley got Maryland voters to make gambling in the state a Constitutional mandate back in 2008?).  In fact, O’Malley has been so successful, he has decided to all but declare his intention to run for President of the United States in 2016.

O’Malley’s Lt. Governor, Anthony Brown, decided to run for Governor this year and won the Democratic primary, which in normal years would mean an automatic win in the General Election.  He outspent his General Election Opponent, Republican businessman Larry Hogan, by at least 2 to 1 in ads.  At the beginning of the year, he was leading in hypothetical polling by 18 points over Hogan, had over 50% support in many polls following the Democratic primary, and held a 7 point lead in the final Baltimore Sun poll leading up to the election.  He was on pace to be the first African-American Governor in Maryland history. No one really seemed to pay attention and just assumed it was a foregone conclusion Brown would trounce Hogan.

And yet…

Election Night came and Larry Hogan won in a decisive manner.  A few votes are still being counted in Baltimore City, but Hogan beat Brown by over 4 points or about 70000 votes.  It was the most stunning result of the night.  Democrats are struggling to explain what happened.

So what happened?  Maybe Hogan pulled Election day chicanery? No.  In fact, there were allegations that the Diebold Electronic Voting booths were registering some of Hogan’s votes as Brown votes.  Was there voter suppression in Maryland?  No.  Again, the rules are designed to favor Democrat voters—no poll tax, no voter ID, no restrictions against voters.  Maybe Hogan had more ad funding than Brown?  No, remember Brown outspent Hogan by 2 to 1.  Maybe racism played a rule in the election?  Nice try.  Hogan’s running mate ended up being the third consecutive African-American Lt. Gov. in the state.  Did top Democrats refuse to endorse Brown?  Not that I’m aware of.

So what happened?  Media analysts are still scratching their heads.  But I know what happened.  Want me to tell you really happened?  You sure?  OK, there were multiple reasons why Hogan beat Brown.  Here are a few:

(1) HOGAN HAD A CAMPAIGN MESSAGE… AND STAYED ON IT FROM DAY 1:  Simply put the message was Marylanders were being taxed too much and people and businesses were fleeing the state for other more tax friendly locals.  40 taxes were raised during O’Malley’s 8 years as Gov., including an infamous “Rain Tax” (more accurately described as a tax to create a fund to clean up the Chesapeake Bay).  People of all political stripes were getting tired of being taxed beyond their means.  In addition, some of the taxes designated for things like transportation were diverted for other purposes—legally, but it made voters mad that the legislature were pleading poverty on transportation funding after raiding those same funds for something else.  Hogan wanted to stop burdening Maryland voters with more taxes and wanted to try and make a state ranked 49th in business climate more friendly.  As for Brown, all he really offered in his campaign was expanding Pre-K education.  In the closing days, he offered to look at business regulations once elected, but it was a half-hearted gesture.  Which leads to point 2…

(2) ANTHONY BROWN RAN A POOR, SLOPPY CAMPAIGN… AND HOGAN RAN A BEAUTIFUL CAMPAIGN:  In short, Brown never took the built-in lead he had after the primary and expand that lead.  He was more interested in campaigning not to lose the election.  He had a distinctively negative tone in his campaign, attacking Hogan with distorted accusations.  It was one of the worst campaigns in Maryland history, and did not really inspire voters to go to the polls.  Instead, Brown tried to win on fear.  Hogan, on the other hand, ran a clean campaign.  Some local analysts even thought it was one of the best campaigns run in recent Maryland history.  Not even last minute appearances by the President and First Lady, who remain popular in the state, could save Brown.  Brown failed to energize his own base.

(3) HOGAN WENT EVERYWHERE… EVEN INTO DEMOCRATIC STRONGHOLDS:  Larry Hogan went across the state in an effort to ask people for their votes.  He talked with voters—not just supporters, but people who probably ended up voting for Brown.  He made an effort to reach out to African-American voters with more than lip-service.  Brown took his base for granted.  That, combined with the negative campaigning, turned off many voters in Montgomery County and possible supporters in Howard and Baltimore Counties.

(4) WHO IS ANTHONY BROWN:  Fact: No Lt. Gov. has ever been promoted to the top position in the State of Maryland.  There a reason for that:  Most Lt. Gov. have been placed on the ballot to check off the box for a special group of voters needed to secure elections.  Once in Annapolis, the #2 position is largely symbolic.  Despite attempts by O’Malley to help raise Brown’s profile, he never really gained traction as a name in Annapolis.  And one of Brown’s high-profile tasks in Annapolis ended up being a debacle.

(5) BROWN RAN THE FAILED STATE HEALTH-CARE EXCHANGE:  Brown was the guy that was supposed to help roll out the State of Maryland Website for Obamacare… and the rollout was a disaster.  First off, with all the smart people supposedly in Maryland, why was a Canadian company chosen to roll out the Website. (Editor’s note:  The reason the Health-care exchange worked so well in Kentucky as opposed to Maryland?  I believe they found the smartest people in Kentucky to help roll out the state exchange and talked to the people of the state to find out what they needed.  There may not be a “whole lot of smart people” in Kentucky, but they found the right people and their exchange worked well).  And it took a while before Maryland admitted their mistake and went with the National Website.  But it cost major money.  And since Brown was the one in charge of the initial botched rollout, he took the blame.

But maybe the last reason is the real reason…

(6 ) PEOPLE WANTED CHANGE:  Anthony Brown didn’t want to distance himself from Martin O’Malley.  And despite O’Malley’s successes in Annapolis, he was losing popularity as the full ramifications of his tax hikes became apparent.  Brown’s failure to bring new ideas to his campaign, largely campaigning for a 3rd O’Malley term turned away his base.  Even normally reliable Democratic voters switched over to vote for a fresh face in Annapolis.

Now, to be fair, Larry Hogan will not have an easy time as Governor in Annapolis.  With Michael Busch and Mike Miller still in control of the legislature, it will not be easy to roll back any of O’Malley’s taxes.  But even if Hogan is unsuccessful, it appears Democrats have gotten the message:  Stop taxing residents at will, start bringing businesses back to Maryland, and start proving you can be good stewards of the state.

The lesson here:  Money doesn’t always win elections.  Neither does an existing voter base advantage.  Having a good message and ground game can overcome the odds—and Hogan certainly had both of those.  His reward is the top position in Maryland for the next 4 years.  Can Hogan capitalize on his success and help build a legitimate opposition to the Maryland Democrat Machine that has steamrolled Republicans over the years?  That remains to be seen…

As for Anthony Brown and his running mate, Ken Ulman?  Their statewide political careers are over.  Democrats in Maryland do not tolerate statewide failures (see Kathleen Kennedy Townsend).  And Martin O’Malley’s Presidential Campaign in 2016 took possibly a fatal hit.  O’Malley may want to focus on taking a few years off, then come back and possibly run for US Senate in 2018 if Ben Cardin retires.  In the end, the Democrats will run a stronger candidate in four years to try and reclaim the top spot.

In the end Hogan was the better choice.  Now comes the hard part for someone who has never held political office before:  governing.  And as for political analysts:  I wondered if they have learned any real lessons from this election cycle.  Maybe, maybe not… But the dumb generalizations about what happened will continue.  Why?  Because it’s easy to come up with an excuse to blame something for losing elections.  That’s just the way we are.  We’re human after all.